Where to start › AI mistakes

AI mistakes that cost owners: who is liable?

8 cases, who paid, and the rules owners use now · Updated · Picked and checked by Olga Pearson

The short answer

In the public cases on this page, the business that used the AI paid for its mistakes. Air Canada was ordered to pay C$812 after its website chatbot misstated policy, and two New York lawyers got a $5,000 court sanction for filing ChatGPT citations they did not check. The owners who avoid this keep the AI away from prices, policies and anything it can change without asking.

This page lists what happened to real businesses. It is not legal advice; ask a lawyer about your own case.

What went wrong, and who paid

BusinessWhat the AI didWhat it costPlay
Air CanadaIts website chatbot misstated its bereavement refund policyOrdered to pay C$812; a tribunal rejected the defense that the bot was responsible as reported, CBS News, Feb 2024Play
Steven A. Schwartz and Peter LoDuca, Levidow, Levidow & ObermanFiled a brief citing court cases ChatGPT had made up$5,000 court sanction as reported, court order, June 2023Play
BMW Toronto dealershipA dealership chatbot presented a buy-back offer more than $7,000 too highThe story made the news as reported, CBC News, Jun 11, 2026Play
Cursor (Anysphere)Its AI support bot invented a policyA public apology from co-founder Michael Truell as reported, The Register, April 2025Play
Sami DaarAsked to find customers on Facebook, the bot joined groups, sent friend requests and messaged people without permissionThe Facebook account was suspended a few hours later self-reportedPlay
Eric Kang, BeatAPIA silent rollback of his shared Grok Bot computerHours of files for 15+ bots wiped in under a minute self-reportedPlay
Ryan Hanley, sports card businessA late-package check passed while an order sat 27 hours with no proof it had shipped, because four orders had no sale timeCaught by the bot’s nightly review; the rerun failed and named the late order self-reportedPlay
Test QuickBooks company (Vadim Chumak)Told “fix my books,” an AI agent made 3 changes in 84 seconds without asking, including a new accountWith write tools switched off it made 0 changes vendor-reportedPlay

Rules owners use so it does not happen to them

  1. Never let a bot name a price, a refund or a policy on its own. Send those to a person. (BMW Toronto, Air Canada, Cursor)
  2. Keep write access off until you have watched it work. Let it describe the fix first. (Vadim Chumak’s test)
  3. Check every citation, number and quote before it leaves the building. (Schwartz and LoDuca)
  4. Check the output, not the log. In Aaron Douglas’s 17-agent marketing practice, a publishing agent’s log said a whole week of posts had gone out, and none were live self-reported. Play
  5. Do not let a bot message strangers for you on a platform that bans it. (Sami Daar)
  6. Back up the bot’s files like code. (Eric Kang)

Questions owners ask

Who is liable when an AI chatbot gives a customer wrong information?

In the public cases in our plays, the business was. Air Canada was ordered to pay C$812 after its chatbot misstated policy, and a tribunal rejected the defense that the bot was responsible (as reported, CBS News). A dealership chatbot’s buy-back offer more than $7,000 too high made the news (as reported, CBC News). Keep prices and policies with a person. This is not legal advice.

Can AI write my contracts and terms?

Owners use it for the first draft, not the final one. Jered Williams, owner of Wahoo Plumbing, has ChatGPT interview him and draft a contract, then his lawyer reviews and fixes it: “Instead of paying two to three thousand for a contract, now I’m paying five to six hundred dollars” (self-reported, play). He says he doesn’t trust ChatGPT to write contracts on its own. Two New York lawyers who filed unchecked ChatGPT citations got a $5,000 sanction, so have a lawyer check anything legal.

How do I stop an AI agent from making changes I did not approve?

Switch off its write tools until you trust it. In a vendor-reported test, an agent told “fix my books” made 3 changes to a test QuickBooks company in 84 seconds without asking; with write tools off it made 0 changes and just described the fix. Approve each change yourself.

More: is it safe to put client info into AI?, what AI costs a small business, all plays, where to start with AI.