Where to start › AI receptionist › What owners report

What 26 owner reports say about AI receptionists

Original count from public posts, every row linked to its source · Updated · Picked and checked by Olga Pearson

The short answer

We found 26 public reports from owners (or about a named business) of an AI answering the business phone. 7 say it paid off, 10 are mixed and 9 are bad. Of the 7 good ones, 3 come from vendor pages. If you count only owners in their own words, with the source reopened, 3 are good.

The pattern: it works best after hours and on overflow. It goes wrong when it answers every call in the day and nobody watches the handoff.

What the good ones have in common

  1. After hours and overflow. Mervin Wickey (TruChoice Roofing) says his AI agent booked 26 sales appointments in 30 days from calls no one answered self-reported. A Jobber user says it has been awesome for overflow and off hours, much better than voicemail self-reported. At Hall’s Heating & Air, about 80% of AI-handled calls came after hours vendor-reported.
  2. It books, not just takes messages. My Smile Miami: 93 bookings in month one; the vendor says the $27,000 figure is estimated booked value, not collected revenue vendor-reported.
  3. It replaces phone staff, not just voicemail. Costa Alexandrou (Nick’s Place) uses it at 3 of 12 locations and hires fewer people to work the phones as reported, Boston Globe.

What went wrong

  1. Some callers hang up when they hear AI. Two Jobber users say so. In a UK boiler firm’s 30-day test, 41 of 214 callers hung up within 10 seconds consultant-reported.
  2. The handoff breaks. In that same test, 21 of 89 captured leads became paid jobs, but two genuine emergency callouts sat unanswered in a dashboard nobody checked until Monday morning consultant-reported, Lilach Bullock.
  3. A person still gets more full intakes. Brandon Theriot (Mobile Diesel Repair) says his AI phone agent completes a full customer intake on 15% to 20% of calls, against about 60% for his partner self-reported, Practical AI Show Ep 59.
  4. What helped: saying it is an AI up front. In the boiler firm test, the consultant says being straight about what it was reduced the hang-up rate over the second half of the month consultant-reported.

All 26 reports

One row per owner. Reddit rows marked “source not reopened” could not be reloaded when we rechecked; they stay in the count with that label.

Good (7)

OwnerBusinessWhat they reportLabelSource
Mervin WickeyTruChoice RoofingAI agent booked 26 sales appointments in 30 days from calls no one answeredSelf-reportedX post · Play
My Smile MiamiDental practice, Miami93 bookings in month one; about $27,000 estimated booked value, not collected revenueVendor-reported (Benian)Vendor page · Play
Hall’s Heating & AirHVAC23 jobs booked in month one; owner reports about 2 hours saved a day; about 80% of AI-handled calls after hoursVendor-reported (Benian)Vendor page · Play
Randi ThompsonBill Joplin’s Air Conditioning and Heating, McKinney, TexasMore than 1,300 calls in just over three months; more than 90% resulted in booked jobs and 72% were completed without a person; the company estimates over $74,000 in added booked revenueVendor press release (ServiceTitan), company estimatesPress release · Play
FredHodgeJrNot stated“Awesome for overflow and off hours,” much better than voicemail; no countJobber forum, self-reportedThread
u/lokikushRepair shopAbout 4 months in, it “captures intent”; they had been losing 30 to 40% of inbound calls beforeReddit, self-reported, source not reopenedThread
Costa AlexandrouNick’s Place (AI at 3 of 12 locations)Says AI is “saving the day” on the phones; cheaper than an employee; hires fewer people for the phonesAs reported, Boston Globe, Jan 18, 2026Article

Mixed (10)

OwnerBusinessWhat they reportLabelSource
TheRealJIMCLOREHome servicesLoves it “even though it isn’t quite what I really need yet”; no call goes to voicemail; captured leads they would probably have missed; “It has saved time”Jobber forum, self-reportedThread
Kent boiler firm, via Lilach BullockBoiler and heating repair, Kent, UK30-day test: 214 calls, 89 captured, 41 hung up within 10 seconds, 21 paid jobs averaging £165 (£3,465 from about £172 spend); two emergency callouts sat unanswered until MondayConsultant-reportedArticle
Tony NaserCrush Pizza and Mickey’s N.Y. PizzaKeeps it: “as time goes on, we get less and less customer complaints about it”; 20 of more than 1,700 Google reviews mention AI or robot phones, most 1 or 2 starsAs reported, Boston Globe, Jan 18, 2026Article
Brandon TheriotMobile Diesel Repair, PhoenixAI phone agent completes a full intake on 15% to 20% of calls; his partner about 60%Self-reported, Practical AI Show Ep 59 (Oct 2, 2026)Episode · Play
Mihail Climov, MDYour Aesthetic Edge, HoustonFirst vendor: “completely do not recommend,” sterile for about 3 months; now a CRM receptionist that is “not bad overall. Takes the call if no one answers or after hours.”Aesthetic Society forum, Sep 9, 2026Thread
HUGEHomeProsHome servicesOff hours only: “hardly anyone stays in the call longer than hearing it’s AI”; “pretty good but I would only use it for after hours stuff”Jobber forumThread
GardsLawnsLawn care“When the ai answers the wheels begin to fall off a bit”; now uses it as a voicemail that can do a quick, easy taskJobber forumThread
Chris_MillerHVACUses the AI as a request taker; the office person calls back to confirm details and a timeJobber forumThread
u/mastafiedInsulation and fire protectionTwo weeks of AI answering everything: people hung up and names and streets were transcribed badly; now AI only after 5 rings or when busyReddit, source not reopenedThread
u/Educational_Cable405Not statedComplaints “basically stopped” once it announced it was automated in the first breathReddit, source not reopenedThread

Bad (9)

OwnerBusinessWhat they reportLabelSource
aarontreeTree company“At best average; and often annoying”; mismatched clients and more dropped balls; “We turned it off after trying it quite a bit.”Jobber forumReply
easpotlessridesNot statedCallers “all hang up as soon as they here AI receptionist”Jobber forumThread
MrElectroNot statedPeople didn’t like it; “for me it didn’t work out well so turned it off”Jobber forumThread
WiringByronNot stated“We were using it and now we’ve put it on hold. I feel like it was decent and then started struggling.”Jobber forumReply
Colleen FriesRingCentral customerThe AI interrupts callers and does not end calls after scheduling; no payoff figureRingCentral forum, Mar 10, 2026Thread
u/pholland167Roofing“It worked fine, nothing amazing. But it didn’t provide us with any more leads vs. baseline and it cost a lot. So we scrapped it.”Reddit, source not reopenedThread
u/AlexSanchez929RoofingGoing back to a live answering service that converts higher; says most callers hang up halfway throughReddit, source not reopenedThread
u/MpidcarterTested only“Very easy to be tripped up and then you’re stuck in a loop.”Reddit, source not reopenedThread
u/Cloudy_Crane3559Repair business testVoice was fine; the handoff to the CRM was broken, with details dumped into a shared inbox nobody ownedReddit, source not reopenedThread

Also related, not in the 26

  • Achint Singh, Belong Law: an outbound AI that calls back website leads who did not book. “This bot has been live for maybe two weeks and we’ve booked 16 grand in revenue because of it.” Booked, not collected self-reported, podcast Play
  • Eric Bandholz, Beardbrand: built his own AI phone support line in about two days; it is now the main support line self-reported Play

How we counted

One row per owner. Good: the owner (or a labeled vendor or consultant page about a named business) says it paid off and they kept it on. Mixed: in use with a real benefit and a serious open problem. Bad: turned off, on hold, scrapped, or callers hang up. Not counted: customer complaints, price comments with no result, and vendor figures not tied to a named business. Counted by Grok Bot, our research bot, from public posts on Nov 12 to 13, 2026, and rechecked on Nov 20, 2026 against every source that would load. We update this page when new owner reports come in.

Questions owners ask

Is an AI receptionist worth it for a small business?

For some. Of 26 public reports we found, 7 say it paid off, 10 are mixed and 9 are bad. Most of the good ones use it after hours or for overflow, like roofer Mervin Wickey, who says his AI agent booked 26 sales appointments in 30 days from calls no one answered (self-reported).

Do customers hang up on AI receptionists?

Some do. Two Jobber users say callers hang up once they hear it is AI. In a UK boiler firm’s 30-day test, 41 of 214 callers hung up within 10 seconds, and the consultant says saying up front that it was an AI reduced the hang-up rate later in the month (consultant-reported).

Is an AI receptionist better than a person?

Not yet for daytime calls, in these reports. Brandon Theriot says his AI phone agent completes a full intake on 15% to 20% of calls, against about 60% for his partner (self-reported). Several owners keep it for after hours and overflow only.

What goes wrong most often?

The handoff. In a UK boiler firm’s 30-day test, two emergency callouts sat unanswered in a dashboard nobody checked until Monday morning (consultant-reported). Decide who reads every AI-taken call, and how fast.

More: is an AI receptionist worth it?, can AI answer my after-hours calls?, is a website chatbot worth it?, all plays, where to start with AI.