All plays › How lawyers and law firms use AI: 6 real plays with results

How lawyers and law firms use AI: 6 real plays with results

6 real plays, each linked to its source · Updated · Picked and checked by Olga Pearson

How do lawyers use AI in a small law firm?

Most law firm owners in these plays use AI first on intake: answering missed calls, screening callers and following up. Billie Tarascio says missed calls fell from 23% to 1% after AI voice intake (self-reported; she credits hiring and marketing too for her client growth). Nancy Cavey added 450 cases in a year with one new hire, using an after-hours AI screener and content marketing (self-reported). Nick Mermiges searched 35 hours of video in about 2 hours with Claude (self-reported). The warning: two New York lawyers were fined $5,000 for filing cases ChatGPT made up.

At a glance

OwnerBusinessResultToolSource datePlay
Billie TarascioLaw firm, about 50 peopleMissed calls 23% to 1%; new clients 24 to 69 a month, which she says also came from hiring and marketing (self-reported)AI voice intake agentApr 2026See the play
Nancy CaveyCavey Law, disability and ERISA law450 new cases in a year with one new hire, from AI plus content marketing (self-reported)After-hours AI voice agent (tool not named)May 15, 2026See the play
Achint SinghBelong Law, immigration and E-2 visas4 to 5 attorney hours a day saved; about $16,000 booked in the first two weeks (as reported)Grok Bot voice agentOct 7, 2026See the play
Nick MermigesHis South Carolina litigation firm35 hours of video evidence searched in about 2 hours (self-reported)ClaudeOct 17, 2026See the play
LangmeiTao IP, patent law firm5 inventors found the firm through AI assistants; the first signed after "book a call" became the first step (self-reported)ChatGPT and other AI assistants (as the referral source)Oct 17, 2026See the play

Each result is as the owner reported it. AI cost is the owner’s own number. Open the play for the source.

Leads3 plays

  • Legal, accounting and financeAI agent (tool not named)

    450 new cases in a year with one new hire at a disability law firm

    self-reported

    Nancy Cavey, founder of a disability and ERISA law firm, says: "Last year, using AI and content marketing, we added 450 new cases while adding only one employee." An after-hours AI voice agent screens callers to her criteria, and a closed in-house AI tool helps clients return completed forms within 24 to 48 hours.

    Nancy Cavey has fought disability insurance and Social Security claims for over 40 years. Her firm accepts only 11.2% of callers and says it wins roughly 90% of those cases, so screening matters. For after-hours calls she put in a custom-trained AI voice agent that does the first interview and screens to her exact criteria; the daytime human intake team stays. A closed, in-house AI tool the firm calls "Betty" helps clients finish their required forms within 24 to 48 hours, and staff review every form. The firm also uses closed AI to draft long appeal briefs and summarize claim files. Growth came from AI plus content marketing together: one blog post becomes a video, a podcast episode, a newsletter feature and handouts.

    By Nancy Cavey, Cavey Law (The Law Offices of Nancy L. Cavey), disability and ERISA law firm · Source

  • Legal, accounting and financeChatGPT and other AI assistants (as the referral source)

    When AI assistants send you leads, put a human call first, not a free tool

    self-reported

    Five inventors found her patent firm through AI assistants like ChatGPT; none used the free online patent check. After she removed it and put “book a call” up front, the first inventor signed the NDA and sent an 80%-complete disclosure.

    Langmei is building Tao IP, a patent law firm. She thought a free self-serve patent check was the most useful thing on her site, but every inbound lead booked a call or sent an inquiry instead, and they wanted to know who the attorney was before sharing anything. She took the tool down and made the calendar the first step.

    By Langmei (@langmei_eth), Tao IP (patent law firm) · Source

  • Legal, accounting and financeGrok Bot

    Have a Grok Bot call abandoned form leads in your own cloned voice

    as reported

    Saves attorneys 4 to 5 hours a day (over $100,000 per year); turns away 10 to 15 unqualified leads a day; earlier interview: about $16,000 booked in the first two weeks.

    Achint Singh of Belong Law (US work and E-2 visas) wired a Grok Bot chain to his Netlify form: when a lead fills it out but doesn’t book, a voice agent calls within minutes in his cloned ElevenLabs voice, qualifies them, texts a calendar link, and logs the call in Attio.

    By Achint Singh (@theachintsingh), Belong Law (immigration / E-2 visas) · Source

Calls and booking1 play

  • Legal, accounting and financeAI voice agent (Lexie Desk, per the transcript)

    Missed calls from 23% to 1% and monthly new clients from 24 to 69 at a law firm

    self-reported

    Law firm owner Billie Tarascio says after switching to an AI voice intake system, "our missed call rate went from 23% to 1%." Self-scheduled appointments went from about 30 to 90, and new clients went from 24 last January to 69 last month. She says not all of that is the AI: "It's also hiring. It's also marketing."

    Billie Tarascio runs a law firm with a team of about 50 and a five-person intake team. She put in an AI voice intake system (she calls it Lexie Desk on the show) that answers every call, captures every caller's information, then follows up and pitches a specific lawyer: "based on your case, this is going to be the best lawyer for you. And here's why. Here's a link to book." If they don't book, it keeps following up. She met her intake team every day during the rollout to get feedback and make tweaks, and kept the people, but says she now needs intake staff with better sales judgment. She says most law firms pay about $1,000 a month for this kind of system.

    By Billie Tarascio, Law firm owner with about 50 people · Source

Checks and safeguards1 play

  • 86’d
    Legal, accounting and financeChatGPT

    Don't send AI-cited sources you never checked

    as reported

    $5,000 court sanction

    Two New York lawyers filed a brief citing court cases ChatGPT had made up. A federal judge fined them and their firm and ordered letters to every real judge named in the fake rulings.

    By Steven A. Schwartz and Peter LoDuca, Levidow, Levidow & Oberman · Source

Research and notes1 play

  • Legal, accounting and financeClaude

    Have AI review hours of video evidence so the client can afford it

    self-reported

    He searched 35 hours of video footage in about 2 hours, work that is normally out of budget for a client, and built a summary from stills and verified transcribed statements.

    Nick Mermiges is a South Carolina litigator who owns his law firm. He uses Claude with saved skills and example libraries to search large volumes of evidence, find patterns of conduct, pull direct quotes from case law, and automate low-level drafting from each case’s facts.

    By Nick Mermiges, Esq. (@NicoTheGreco), His law firm (South Carolina litigation) · Source

More questions owners ask

Which AI do lawyers in these plays use?

Pick by the job; no firm here compared tools side by side. Nick Mermiges uses Claude with saved skills to search evidence and draft. Achint Singh of Belong Law uses a Grok Bot voice agent that calls back form leads who did not book. Billie Tarascio and Nancy Cavey use AI voice intake systems (Cavey's tool is not named), and Cavey's firm uses a closed, in-house AI system rather than public tools.

What are the ethics risks of AI for a law firm?

These plays show three. Made-up citations: two New York lawyers and their firm were fined $5,000 in Mata v. Avianca (2023) for filing cases ChatGPT invented. Client confidentiality: Nancy Cavey warns against putting client details into public AI tools, since a court ruled that can waive privilege. Legal advice by bot: the intake prompts on these plays all tell the AI never to give legal advice. Check every citation yourself and follow your state bar's rules on AI. This is not legal advice.

Can AI answer calls for a law firm?

Yes, in these plays. Billie Tarascio's AI voice intake answers every call, captures the caller's details and sends a booking link that names the best-fit lawyer; she says missed calls went from 23% to 1% (self-reported). Nancy Cavey uses an AI voice agent only after hours and keeps her daytime human intake team. Tarascio met her intake team every day during the rollout to get feedback and make tweaks.

Do AI assistants like ChatGPT send clients to law firms?

One firm here says yes. Langmei says five inventors found her patent firm, Tao IP, through AI assistants like ChatGPT (self-reported). None used the free patent check on her site; they wanted to know who the attorney was first, so she took the tool down and made "book a call" the first step. Five leads is a small sample.